Watch Out For That Pig-in-a-Poke Valuation

“Jim, I decided to go with the other firm. They say they can get more for my company than you think it’s worth.”

This recent comment from Tracy (not her real name) was the first time in ten years I have lost an engagement because the business owner was picking another intermediary. It seems the other broker convinced Tracy that he could get her a higher price for her company.

I had told Tracy the business could be sold for $4 to $5 million. The other broker told her that he could sell the business for $8 million. How do you explain such a wide swing? Oftentimes, a business owner is lured to sell their business by an overly optimistic valuation, the result of inexperience, or a not-so-veiled effort to land the engagement based on false hope. Simply said, there are brokers who will hype the valuation in an effort to get the engagement.

Tracy was understandably excited to hear her business could be sold for $8 million. Even though the other broker had a higher fee than mine, the net to Tracy (assuming the business could be sold for $8 million) would be about $2.25 million higher. So, mathematically, I could hardly blame Tracy for her decision. The problem being, of course, the business will not sell for $8 million. The other broker gave her a pig-in-a-poke promise.

So how does a business owner avoid wasting time on a pig-in-a-poke promise? First, do not rely on the opinion of just one broker (a/k/a, intermediary, M&A consultant). Second, if you get opinions of value with a differential of 15% or more, ask your accountant to interview two brokers you are considering. Third, engage the input of your wealth planner (financial advisor). He or she might not know how businesses are valued, but they likely understand basic financial principles pretty well, and their instinctive opinion should be a valuable consideration in your decision.

I leave you with one simple premise: don’t select a broker just because you like his/her opinion of value. They might be bringing you a pig-in-a-poke valuation.

JIM CUMBEE is President of Tennessee Valley Group, Inc. a retainer-based business brokerage and transition mediation firm in Franklin, TN. Cumbee is an attorney and has an MBA from Harvard Business School. Jim is the author of Home Run, A Pro’s Guide to Selling a Business. https://www.amazon.com/Home-Pros-Guide-Selling-Business/dp/1599329239 .  He has a wide range of corporate and entrepreneurial experiences that make him one of the most sought-after business transition advisors in the state of Tennessee. The names and fact patterns above have been changed to preserve the parties’ identities.

The following two tabs change content below.

Tennessee Valley Group

Jim Cumbee established Tennessee Valley Group to help business owners fulfill their dreams for life after business ownership. It’s a mission that his 30+ year career history had prepared him well for—in addition to being an attorney, transition mediator and business broker, Jim has been a buyer, seller, and entrepreneur. His broad range of experience gives him unique insight into how business buyers and sellers can achieve their goals.

Latest posts by Tennessee Valley Group (see all)